Table of Contents
A divorce decree is conclusive and final. However, a party can attack a final divorce decree or its terms if they establish extrinsic fraud. What is extrinsic fraud? What elements are necessary to state a case? In Bates v. Bates, 400 P.2d 593 (1965) the Arizona Court of Appeals discussed these issues.
Facts and Procedure
Mrs. Bates and Mr. Bates married in 1924 and had two children. They divorced in 1950. The couple signed a property settlement agreement that gave Mrs. Bates custody of the minor child. It also gave her $50 monthly support for the child and $50 per month alimony.
Under the agreement, Mr. Bates got all of the community property as his separate property. The property settlement agreement did not specify the community property. Over a decade later, Mrs. Bates learned that, during the marriage, Mr. Bates had bought a secret interest in real property. He concealed the interest from her by buying it in someone else’s name. He sold the interest in the property, called the Dendora Ranch, for $184,456.33. She sued for an accounting and a tenant in common interest.
Mr. Bates moved to dismiss her complaint saying it was a collateral attack on a judgment. The court granted his motion. Mrs. Bates appealed.
Facts Admitted by Husband
The Court of Appeals noted that the husband had accepted various facts in his motion to dismiss. These included the following points:
• That during his marriage, he secretly purchased real estate with community funds
• That he had the title put in the name of another person to hide his ownership from Mrs. Bates
• That Mrs. Bates did not know of the property at the time of the divorce
• That she did not discover the facts about it until just before the filing of her complaint
• That Mr. Bates sold the real property for $184,456.33
• That the property was the community property of Mrs. Bates and Mr. Bates
• That it was never mentioned or known to the court
Attacking a Decree for Extrinsic Fraud
The wife claims that the husband obtained the divorce decree by extrinsic fraud. If so, equity requires that he held the property in constructive trust for her. A constructive trust is one which does not arise by agreement, but by operation of law. Fraud is an essential element. Actual fraud is not always necessary.
A constructive trust arises if someone gets property in a way that makes it unfair for that person to keep the title. Mrs. Bates can make a claim for relief from extrinsic fraud in an independent action asking for equitable relief as she has done here.
The Court noted that she had another option as well. She can also attack the fraud by attacking the divorce decree since it appears Mr. Bates was never properly served. If the decree is void, Mrs. Bates could establish her ownership and interest in the property. This might be under a constructive trust or under the theory of undistributed community property. The Court left it to Mrs. Bates’ attorneys to determine which way to proceed was best.
Wife’s Complaint States a Cause of Action
The Court noted that a judgment must be regarded as final and conclusive. However, it is not final if fraud obtained the jurisdiction of the court. It can be attacked if the prevailing party, by some extrinsic or collateral fraud, prevented a fair submission of the case.
Mrs. Bates’ case must come within this exception to state a cause of action. The Court of Appeals said that if fraud is extrinsic, an attack is a direct, not a collateral attack, as the trial court found. It found that the wife’s complaint stated a cause of action based on extrinsic fraud. It held that the divorce decree was therefore not conclusive. Therefore, Mrs. Bates was not estopped to bring this action, nor is it barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
Disposition
The Court of Appeals reversed the ruling below. It remanded the case with instructions to deny the husband’s motion to dismiss. It also ordered the trial court to permit Mrs. Bates to amend her complaint.
If you have questions about extrinsic fraud in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona divorce and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in divorce and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona divorce or family law case around today.
More Articles About Divorce in Arizona
- The advantage of Filing Divorce First in Arizona
- Are Prenuptial Agreements Enforceable in Arizona
- Arizona Divorce
- Arizona Divorce Attorney Reviews
- Arizona Divorce Child Custody
- Arizona Divorce Debt
- Arizona Divorce Forms
- Arizona Divorce Laws
- Arizona Divorce Laws Alimony
- Arizona Divorce Laws and Statutes
- Arizona Divorce Laws on Adultery
- Arizona Divorce Papers
- Arizona Divorce Practice
- Arizona Divorce Process
- Arizona Divorce Records Search
- Arizona Marriage Laws
- Asset and Property Search in an Arizona Divorce
- Arizona Divorce When You Can’t Find Your Spouse
- Change to Maiden Name After Divorce in Arizona
- Changing Orders in an Arizona Divorce Decree
- Children and Divorce in Arizona
- College Expenses After Divorce in Arizona
- Complex Divorce Cases in Arizona
- Conciliation Court Services in Arizona
- Consent Required for Marriage of Minors in Arizona
- Considering the Children during a Divorce in Arizona
- Convert to a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- Coping With Divorce in Arizona
- Court Services to Save a Marriage in Arizona
- Custody of the Family Pet in a Divorce in Arizona
- Dissolution of Marriage in Arizona
- Divorce After Legal Separation in Arizona
- Divorce and Children in Arizona
- Divorce Arizona
- Divorce Case is on the Inactive Calendar in Arizona
- Divorce Court Jurisdiction in Arizona
- Divorce in Arizona Without Children
- Divorce Procedures in Arizona
- Divorce Records in Arizona
- Divorce Statistics in Arizona
- Divorce Support Groups in Arizona
- Domestic Violence and Divorce in Arizona
- Effect of Adultery on an Arizona Divorce
- Effects of Divorce on Children in Arizona
- Enforceable Arizona Prenuptial Agreements
- Failure to Include an Issue in an Arizona Divorce
- Filing for Divorce in Arizona
- Filing for Divorce to Receive Alimony in Arizona
- Guide to Divorce for Men in Arizona
- High Asset Divorce in Arizona
- High Conflict Divorce in Arizona
- High Net Worth Divorce Arizona
- How is a Divorce Finalized in Arizona
- How Long Does a Contested Divorce Take in Arizona
- How Long Does it Take to Get a Divorce in Arizona
- How Long Does it Take to Get Divorced in Arizona
- How Long Does Uncontested Divorce Take in Arizona
- How Long To Be Separated Before Divorce in Arizona
- How long to get Temporary Orders in Arizona
- How Much Does it Cost to Get a Divorce in Arizona
- How to Appeal a Divorce Decree in Arizona
- How To Find Good Divorce Attorney in Arizona
- How to Start a Divorce in Arizona
- Learn About Uncontested Divorce in Arizona
- Legally Separated File Divorce in Arizona
- Marital Settlement Agreement in Arizona
- The merger of the Settlement Agreement in Arizona
- Military Divorce Laws in Arizona
- Misled Into Signing Divorce Settlement in Arizona
- Modifying a Divorce Decree in Arizona
- No Contest Divorce in Arizona
- No-Fault Divorce in Arizona
- Order to Pay Spouses Attorney Fees in Arizona
- Parenting Class During a Divorce in Arizona
- Petition for Dissolution of Marriage in Arizona
- Protect Children in a Divorce in Arizona
- Quick Divorce in Arizona
- Reasons for Divorce in Arizona
- Reasons to File for Divorce in Arizona
- Represent Yourself in Arizona Divorce Case
- Same-Sex Divorce in Arizona
- Sealing Court Records in an Arizona Divorce
- Sell Home During Divorce in Arizona
- Selling Property During a Divorce in Arizona
- Served With Divorce Papers in Arizona
- Serving Divorce Papers by Publication in Arizona
- Should I Keep the House in a Divorce in Arizona
- Social Media Evidence in Divorce in Arizona
- Stop an Arizona Divorce
- Stop an Arizona Divorce if You Change Your Mind
- What Happens at a Resolution Management Conference in Arizona
- What Happens If the Divorce Case Goes to Trial in Arizona
- What Happens Temporary Orders Hearing in Arizona
- What is a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- What is a Default Divorce in Arizona
- What is a Family Law Master in an Arizona Divorce Case
- What is a Preliminary Injunction in an Arizona Divorce
- What is a Temporary Orders Hearing in Arizona
- What is the Divorce Process in Arizona
- What Reasons Do I Need to Obtain a Divorce in a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- What to do When Served with Divorce Papers in Arizona
- When Can I File For Divorce in Arizona
As Seen on CBS News, ABC News, NBC News, and Fox News
What’s Hot – Blog
About the Author: Chris Hildebrand has over 26 years of Arizona family law experience and received awards from US News and World Report, Phoenix Magazine, Arizona Foothills Magazine and others. Visit https://www.hildebrandlaw.com.