Changing Judges in an Arizona Divorce
Many people have asked about changing judges in an Arizona divorce. In Arizona, either party can obtain a change of judge by following the requirements of Rule 42(f)(1) of the Arizona Rules of Family Law Procedure.
But what happens when the judge the party seeks to remove in a divorce declines to be removed? In Taliaferro v. Taliaferro, 921 P.2d 21 (1996) the Arizona Supreme Court considered the consequences of such a situation.
Mr. Taliaferro asked for a dissolution of marriage from his wife, Mrs. Taliaferro, and sought an Order of Protection. Judge Topf granted the Order of Protection on January 27, 1993. Mrs. Taliaferro filed a change of judicial notice under Rule 42(f). Judge Rogers took over the case. Mrs. Taliaferro submitted the Order of Protection to Judge Rogers for rehearing. The husband appeared but did not stay for the hearing and the judge dismissed the Order of Protection.
In February 1993, Mr. Taliaferro filed a notice of change of judge as to Judge Rogers. But Judge Rogers denied husband’s notice of change of judge. He did so “for the reason that a scheduled, contested hearing has taken place before this Court.” The husband did not seek special action relief from this denial. Instead, the case went to trial before Judge Rogers. On August 24, Judge Rogers signed a lengthy final judgment. It ordered the husband’s lawyer to pay the wife’s attorney fees and to pay sanctions.
Both husband and his lawyer, Mr. Hirschfeld, appealed to the court of appeals. The Court of Appeals ruled that Mr. Taliaferro could raise the change of judge issue on appeal. It ruled that once the notice was filed, Judge Rogers had no subject matter jurisdiction to proceed. It vacated the final decree. The Arizona Supreme Court granted review.
A Notice of Change of Judge Does Not Affect the Court’s Jurisdiction
Clinton’s attorney claimed that Judge Rogers did not have subject matter jurisdiction after the change-of-judge notice was filed. The Arizona Supreme Court disagreed. It found that the notice of change of judge did not affect the subject matter jurisdiction of the court.
The Court discussed the meaning of the term “jurisdiction” in Rule 42(f). The judiciary amended Rule 42 to give a party the right to a change of judge. Before this amendment, a party challenged a judge via a peremptory challenge. This was accomplished by a pro forma affidavit of bias and prejudice. These affidavits were also used for challenges for cause.
This created a blurred distinction between a peremptory challenge and a challenge for cause. Courts began to use the word “jurisdiction” in the context of affidavits of bias and prejudice. But, the Court noted, “jurisdiction” means different things in different contexts. Sometimes it is used to describe the authority to do a particular thing. In another, it means the court’s power to entertain an action of a particular subject matter.
The use of “jurisdiction” in Rule 42(f) is ambiguous. As written, the rule could talk about the authority to hear a case or it could refer to subject matter jurisdiction. However, the Arizona Constitution vests the superior court with jurisdiction to hear divorce proceedings. The judiciary cannot, under its rule-making power, reduce the constitutional grant of jurisdiction.
An erroneous ruling on a change-of-judge notice cannot shrink the court’s subject matter jurisdiction. This is reflected in the case law. It provides that the judge who decides the propriety of the notice under Rule 42 is the noticed judge. That means that the filing of the notice does not deprive that judge of power to act.
Even Rule 42(f)(3) allows the noticed judge to make temporary orders before transferring the action to another judge. Therefore, the noticed judge does not lose subject matter of a case because of a Rule 42 filing. If the noticed judge fails to honor a change-of-judge notice, the injured party must be able to seek relief. A party waiting to challenge it until appeal after final judgment will have to show prejudice from the error. This is virtually impossible to do.
Denial of Change of Judge in Arizona Should Be Challenged by Special Action Relief
In addition, it is not practical for these issues to be raised in post-judgment appeals. That would allow a party to overturn an entire case after it is completed. Once a judgment has been entered in a civil matter, it’s too late to rethink the judge.
The court system must have an opportunity to review a ruling on the propriety of a notice before the judge presides over the case. Special action relief provides that opportunity. A party wishing to test rulings about a peremptory challenge of a judge must seek special action relief.
In this case, the husband never sought special action relief. He filed this appeal months after the trial court denied his notice of change of judge. The case was determined at trial. Clinton cannot now raise errors in connection with the notice of change of judge.
The Arizona Supreme Court ruled that a party challenging a ruling on a change-of—judge notice must seek special action relief. It vacated the court of appeals decision and remanded the case for consideration of issues properly raised on appeal.
If you have questions about changing judges in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona divorce and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in divorce and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona divorce or family law case around today.
More Articles About Divorce in Arizona
- The advantage of Filing Divorce First in Arizona
- Are Prenuptial Agreements Enforceable in Arizona
- Arizona Divorce
- Arizona Divorce Attorney Reviews
- Arizona Divorce Child Custody
- Arizona Divorce Debt
- Arizona Divorce Forms
- Arizona Divorce Laws
- Arizona Divorce Laws Alimony
- Arizona Divorce Laws and Statutes
- Arizona Divorce Laws on Adultery
- Arizona Divorce Papers
- Arizona Divorce Practice
- Arizona Divorce Process
- Arizona Divorce Records Search
- Arizona Marriage Laws
- Asset and Property Search in an Arizona Divorce
- Arizona Divorce When You Can’t Find Your Spouse
- Change to Maiden Name After Divorce in Arizona
- Changing Orders in an Arizona Divorce Decree
- Children and Divorce in Arizona
- College Expenses After Divorce in Arizona
- Complex Divorce Cases in Arizona
- Conciliation Court Services in Arizona
- Consent Required for Marriage of Minors in Arizona
- Considering the Children during a Divorce in Arizona
- Convert to a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- Coping With Divorce in Arizona
- Court Services to Save a Marriage in Arizona
- Custody of the Family Pet in a Divorce in Arizona
- Dissolution of Marriage in Arizona
- Divorce After Legal Separation in Arizona
- Divorce and Children in Arizona
- Divorce Arizona
- Divorce Case is on the Inactive Calendar in Arizona
- Divorce Court Jurisdiction in Arizona
- Divorce in Arizona Without Children
- Divorce Procedures in Arizona
- Divorce Records in Arizona
- Divorce Statistics in Arizona
- Divorce Support Groups in Arizona
- Domestic Violence and Divorce in Arizona
- Effect of Adultery on an Arizona Divorce
- Effects of Divorce on Children in Arizona
- Enforceable Arizona Prenuptial Agreements
- Failure to Include an Issue in an Arizona Divorce
- Filing for Divorce in Arizona
- Filing for Divorce to Receive Alimony in Arizona
- Guide to Divorce for Men in Arizona
- High Asset Divorce in Arizona
- High Conflict Divorce in Arizona
- High Net Worth Divorce Arizona
- How is a Divorce Finalized in Arizona
- How Long Does a Contested Divorce Take in Arizona
- How Long Does it Take to Get a Divorce in Arizona
- How Long Does it Take to Get Divorced in Arizona
- How Long Does Uncontested Divorce Take in Arizona
- How Long To Be Separated Before Divorce in Arizona
- How long to get Temporary Orders in Arizona
- How Much Does it Cost to Get a Divorce in Arizona
- How to Appeal a Divorce Decree in Arizona
- How To Find Good Divorce Attorney in Arizona
- How to Start a Divorce in Arizona
- Learn About Uncontested Divorce in Arizona
- Legally Separated File Divorce in Arizona
- Marital Settlement Agreement in Arizona
- The merger of the Settlement Agreement in Arizona
- Military Divorce Laws in Arizona
- Misled Into Signing Divorce Settlement in Arizona
- Modifying a Divorce Decree in Arizona
- No Contest Divorce in Arizona
- No-Fault Divorce in Arizona
- Order to Pay Spouses Attorney Fees in Arizona
- Parenting Class During a Divorce in Arizona
- Petition for Dissolution of Marriage in Arizona
- Protect Children in a Divorce in Arizona
- Quick Divorce in Arizona
- Reasons for Divorce in Arizona
- Reasons to File for Divorce in Arizona
- Represent Yourself in Arizona Divorce Case
- Same-Sex Divorce in Arizona
- Sealing Court Records in an Arizona Divorce
- Sell Home During Divorce in Arizona
- Selling Property During a Divorce in Arizona
- Served With Divorce Papers in Arizona
- Serving Divorce Papers by Publication in Arizona
- Should I Keep the House in a Divorce in Arizona
- Social Media Evidence in Divorce in Arizona
- Stop an Arizona Divorce
- Stop an Arizona Divorce if You Change Your Mind
- What Happens at a Resolution Management Conference in Arizona
- What Happens If the Divorce Case Goes to Trial in Arizona
- What Happens Temporary Orders Hearing in Arizona
- What is a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- What is a Default Divorce in Arizona
- What is a Family Law Master in an Arizona Divorce Case
- What is a Preliminary Injunction in an Arizona Divorce
- What is a Temporary Orders Hearing in Arizona
- What is the Divorce Process in Arizona
- What Reasons Do I Need to Obtain a Divorce in a Covenant Marriage in Arizona
- What to do When Served with Divorce Papers in Arizona
- When Can I File For Divorce in Arizona
Chris Hildebrand wrote the information on this page about a notice for change of judge in an Arizona divorce to ensure everyone has access to information about family law in Arizona. Chris is a divorce and family law attorney at Hildebrand Law, PC. He has over 24 years of Arizona family law experience and has received multiple awards, including US News and World Report “Top Arizona Divorce Attorneys”, Phoenix Magazine “Top Divorce Law Firms”, and Arizona Foothills Magazine “Best of the Valley” award. He believes the policies and procedures he uses to get his clients through a divorce should all be guided by the principles of honesty, integrity, and, quite frankly, actually caring about what his clients are going through in a divorce or family law case. In short, his practice is defined by the success of his clients. He also manages all of the other attorneys at his firm to make sure the outcomes in their clients’ cases are successful as well.
As Seen on CBS News, ABC News, NBC News, and Fox News
What’s Hot – Blog
About the Author: Chris Hildebrand has over 26 years of Arizona family law experience and received awards from US News and World Report, Phoenix Magazine, Arizona Foothills Magazine and others.