Can A Judge Consider Prior Change in Circumstances for a Child Custody Modification in Arizona
In Arizona, a parent must show a substantial and continuing change in circumstances has occurred that justifies a trial to determine if a change in custody of a child should be ordered.
This means that a parent must file a petition to modify child custody and that petition must include new allegations of specific facts demonstrating that sufficient changes have occurred since the last child custody order was entered before a trial can be scheduled.
If a parent fails to demonstrate a sufficient change has occurred since the last child custody order was entered, the petition for modification of child custody is denied and the trial is not scheduled.
It is important to note that the alleged changes cannot be based only allegations of events that occurred before the last child custody order was entered.
The question becomes whether a judge can consider allegations of events that occurred before the last child custody order was entered if a parent establishes that a change in circumstances has occurred after the last child custody order was entered.
Prior Allegations in a New Petition to Modify Custody
The Arizona Supreme Court answered that question in the case of Pridgeon vs. Superior Court. In the Pridgeon case, the father filed a petition to modify custody of the parties’ child. In his petition to modify, the father included allegations that predated the prior child custody orders.
The mother argued the father could not include any allegations in his petition for modification of custody that predated the issuance of the last custody order.
The Arizona Supreme Court cited decisions reached in the case of Bailey vs. Bailey in which the Arizona Supreme Court ruled that “a custody order is final on the facts that were before the court when its decision was made.”
However, it held that once a given set of circumstances has been presented to the court in a child custody proceeding, those same circumstances may not be alleged again to modify a child custody order.
However, it also ruled that once additional changes in circumstances are alleged concerning new circumstances that occurred after the last child support order was entered justifying a potential modification of a child custody order, those prior circumstances may then be alleged as additional support for a petition to modify child custody.
The Supreme Court stated a judge cannot be held to make a decision in a child custody modification case in a vacuum. It recognized that the significance of events that occurred after the child custody order was last issued may, in some cases, only be understood in the context of understanding events that occurred before the last child custody order was entered.
The court went on to say that decisions on the admissibility of evidence must not be made based upon whether it relates to events that occurred before the last child custody order was entered but, instead, by its relevance to circumstances that occurred after the last child custody order was entered.
A judge, therefore, can consider both new allegations as well as allegations that were either previously alleged or concern circumstances already considered by the court in a prior child custody hearing if a parent first establishes at least one substantial and continuing change in circumstances since the last child custody order was issued when determining if a parent has established adequate cause to hold a modification of child custody hearing.
On a related note, the Arizona Supreme Court also ruled that a petition to modify custody of a child must state specific facts and cannot simply be conclusory statements.
Furthermore, the Supreme Court indicated a court is required to schedule a trial if the other parent files a contravening affidavit disputing the facts alleged in the other parent’s affidavit of changed circumstances because a trial court cannot conduct a “trial by affidavit” by judging the credibility of the statements in the competing affidavits.
If you have questions about change in circumstances: custody modification in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona child custody and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in child custody and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona child custody or family law case around today.
More Articles About Child Custody in Arizona
- Access to a Child’s Medical Records in Arizona
- Adoption Attorneys in Arizona
- Required Affidavit in a Child Custody Case in Arizona
- Are Mothers Favored Custody Battles in Arizona
- Arizona Child Custody Attorneys
- Arizona Child Custody Statutes
- Arizona Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act Statutes
- Changing a Child’s Last Name in Arizona
- Changing Child Custody in Arizona
- Child Custody and Child Support in Arizona
- Child Custody In Arizona
- Child Custody Laws in Arizona
- Child Custody Rights in Arizona
- Co-Parenting After Divorce in Arizona
- Custody of a Child to Grandparent in Arizona
- Delegation of Custody Decisions in Arizona
- Divorce and Grandparents Visitation in Arizona
- Effective Co-Parenting in Arizona
- Emergency Child Custody in Arizona
- Emergency Child Custody Orders in Arizona
- Enforce Parenting Time or Custody in Arizona
- Enforce Visitation Non-Custodial Parent in Arizona
- Grandparent’s Rights in Arizona
- How is Child Custody Determined in Arizona
- How to Change a Child’s Last Name in Arizona
- How to Enforce Parenting Time in Arizona
- How to Get Sole Custody in Arizona
- How to Modify Child Custody in Arizona
- How to Modify Visitation in Arizona
- Joint Custody and School Decisions in Arizona
- Joint Custody vs Sole Custody Arizona
- Joint Legal Custody or Joint Decision Making in Arizona
- Modifying Visitation With a Child in Arizona
- Moving Children Many Times in Arizona
- Order of Protection and Child Custody in Arizona
- Parent Information Program Class in Arizona
- Parent Move Out of State With A Child From Arizona
- Parental Alienation in Arizona
- Prepare for Child Custody Evaluation in Arizona
- Presumption of Equal Parenting Time in Arizona
- Restrictions in Arizona on Taking Children to Another Country
- Sole Legal Custody or Sole Decision Making in Arizona
- Sole or Joint Custody in Arizona
- Temporary Child Custody in Arizona
- Uniform Child Custody Jurisdiction and Enforcement Act in Arizona
- What Are the Child Custody Factors in Arizona
- What Determines Child Custody in Arizona
- What is a Child Custody Evaluation in Arizona
- What is a Parenting Coordinator in an Arizona Child Custody Case
- What Is Domestic Violence in Arizona
- What Types of Child Custody Are There in Arizona
- What Visitation or Parenting Time Schedules do Judges Order in Arizona
- Who Has Custody of Children When a Divorce is Filed in Arizona
- Who Is the Best Child Custody Lawyer in Arizona
- Withholding Child From Custodial Parent in Arizona
Chris Hildebrand wrote the information on this page about the modification of child custody in Arizona to ensure everyone has access to information about child custody laws in Arizona. Chris is a family law attorney at Hildebrand Law, PC. He has over 24 years of Arizona family law experience and has received multiple awards, including US News and World Report “Top Arizona Divorce Attorneys”, Phoenix Magazine “Top Divorce Law Firms”, and Arizona Foothills Magazine “Best of the Valley” award. He believes the policies and procedures he uses to get his clients through a child custody case should all be guided by the principles of honesty, integrity, and actually caring about what his clients are going through.