Do you have questions about the division of Deferred Retirement Option Plans in an Arizona divorce?
Well, the Arizona Court of Appeals in the memorandum decisions of Lambert vs. Sheets issued a ruling on whether an Arizona Deferred Retirement Option Plan, also know as the DROP program, was subject to being divided in a divorce in Arizona. The following is the Arizona Court of Appeals decision in that case.
In that case, Mr. Sheets (“Husband”) appeals the superior court’s post-decree domestic relations order awarding Ms. Lambert (“Wife”) a pro rata share of any cumulative interest in his Deferred Retirement Option Plan (“DROP”) account.
Wife cross-appeals the court’s denial of her request for attorney’s fees.
For the following reasons, we affirm the denial of fees, vacate the order in part, and remand for further proceedings.
Wife served Husband with a petition for dissolution of marriage in March 2012.
At the time, Husband was eligible to retire under the Arizona Public Safety Personnel Retirement System (“PSPRS”) pension plan.
He was eligible to receive $3,930.84 per month in benefits upon retirement but chose to continue working. He was qualified to participate in DROP, see A.R.S. §§ 38-844.02 et seq., but had not elected to do so.
In November 2015, the parties finalized their dissolution of marriage and consent decree that incorporated a property settlement agreement (“PSA”).
The parties agreed to divide Husband’s PSPRS benefit pursuant to Koelsch v. Koelsch, 148 Ariz. 176 (1986).
Under the agreement, each party received 50% of the community interest accrued through the date of service of the divorce petition.
Spousal Maintenance and Deferred Retirement Option Plans
The parties also agreed that Husband would make the remaining payments on their joint Chapter 13 bankruptcy plan and would thereafter pay Wife monthly, as non-modifiable spousal maintenance, “one-half of the community monthly benefit Husband would have been entitled to receive from PSPRS as of the date of service of the divorce petition.”
The parties agreed to the amount of $1,965.42 in spousal maintenance.
Upon Husband’s retirement, spousal maintenance would terminate, Wife would receive a portion of the PSPRS benefit in “the amount Husband had been paying as spousal maintenance,” and Husband would receive the remainder.
The wife would not receive an increased benefit resulting from Husband’s additional service “because she commenced receiving benefits at the earlier date.”
The parties also agreed that the prevailing party in an action to enforce the PSA would be entitled to recover reasonable attorney’s fees.
The next year, Wife sought a domestic relations order in connection with her interest in the PSPRS benefit.
Husband objected to the provision in the proposed order allocating Wife “a pro-rata share of any DROP benefits and contributions” made by him, should he elect to participate in DROP.
The wife then amended her proposed order to provide her a share of the “cumulative interest” in Husband’s DROP account.
Husband again objected, arguing that because Wife had “commenced receiving benefits at the earlier date,” she would not be funding the DROP account and therefore, was not entitled to any portion of it.
After an evidentiary hearing, the court determined that Husband’s decision to participate in DROP would “place his PSPRS accrued funds into DROP, from which he will receive a lump sum upon retirement.”
The court concluded that such a decision “has the result of depositing his entire PSPRS account into an interest-bearing deferred compensation account.”
Therefore, “[Wife] would be entitled to calculate her 50% of the community interest to include interest earned in DROP.”
Finally, the court held that the interest earned in DROP constituted an increase due to the “intrinsic quality” of the retirement plan in which Wife would be entitled to share. See Koelsch, 48 Ariz. at 185. The court awarded Wife
(1) an amount equal to 50% of Husband’s pension benefit accrued under the PSPRS as of March 16, 2012, and
(2) “a pro rata share of any cumulative interest accumulated under DROP.” (Emphasis in original.)
The court denied Wife’s request for attorney’s fees.
Following several post-trial motions, Husband appealed, and Wife cross-appealed. We have jurisdiction pursuant to A.R.S. § 12- 2101(A)(2). See Boncoskey v. Boncoskey, 216 Ariz. 448, 451 (App. 2007) (recognizing the right to appeal from a qualified domestic relations order as a special order after final judgment).
Husband argues the court erred by awarding Wife a share in the cumulative interest in the DROP account. See A.R.S. § 25-318(A).
Although property acquired during the marriage is presumed to be community property, property acquired after service of the dissolution petition is separate property if the petition results in a decree of dissolution. A.R.S. §§ 25-211(A)(2), -213(B); Brebaugh v. Deane, 211 Ariz. 95, 97–98 (App. 2005).
“The characterization of property as separate or community is a question of law we review de novo.” Schickner v. Schickner, 237 Ariz. 194, 199 (App. 2015).
The dispositive question is whether Wife’s property interest in the PSPRS benefit will be used to generate the accumulated interest in Husband’s DROP account.
We conclude that it will not.
Upon Husband’s participation in DROP, he must designate a retirement date no later than five years from the date of his decision and he must retire on the designated date. See A.R.S. §§ 38-844.02, -844.03(A)–(B).
By participating, Husband will not accrue benefits under PSPRS, but rather, his “normal retirement benefit” will be deposited into an interest-bearing account. See A.R.S. §§ 38- 844.03(B)(2)–(4), -844.05.
In accordance with the consent decree, Husband pays $1,965.42 per month to Wife, which compensates her for the interest in the PSPRS benefit that is delayed by his decision not to retire. See Koelsch, 148 Ariz. at 185.
Because Wife’s property interest in the PSPRS benefit will not be used to accumulate interest in Husband’s DROP account, she will not be contributing a share of the “normal retirement benefit” to the account.
Accordingly, Wife is not entitled to draw on either the principal or the interest.
Wife contends that the cumulative interest in DROP may be considered an after-discovered asset and divided under A.R.S. § 25-318(D).
We hold otherwise.
Wife’s argument presumes that the accumulated interest is community property.
However, as noted in Koelsch, an increase in the value of a pension benefit is separate property if it is based on the employee spouse’s efforts after dissolution and is community property if it is based on “the inherent quality of the pension plan.” 148 Ariz. at 184 n.9 (citation omitted).
We agree with Husband that DROP is the former, not the latter.
An “inherent quality” increase is granted “regardless of whether the employee was still working or had retired.” Id.
Here, Husband must continue working and participate in DROP.
Therefore, any increase in the value of his retirement benefit would be attributable to his own post-marital effort and funds, not unexpected or passive appreciation.
Spousal Maintenance and Interest, What is Fair?
The wife further argues that the court correctly classified the monthly payments as non-modifiable spousal maintenance.
From this proposition, she reasons that her receipt of $1,965.42 per month should not be treated as her share of the PSPRS benefits.
The parties’ own agreement for spousal maintenance belies this argument.
By providing that Wife was entitled to non-modifiable payments in an amount equal to her monthly interest in Husband’s retirement benefits, the agreement makes clear that Wife received the full measure of her property interest and contributed nothing to any future DROP account.
Finally, Wife argues the superior court erred by denying her request for attorney’s fees as the prevailing party in an action to enforce the PSA when it found that A.R.S. § 25-324 “overrides” the prevailing-party provision in the PSA.
Given that Wife is no longer the prevailing party, we decline to address this issue.
For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the denial of Wife’s request for attorney’s fees, vacate the order to the extent it awards Wife a share of any cumulative interest accumulated under DROP, and remand for modification of the order indicating that Wife is entitled to neither the principal nor the interest in the DROP account.
Wife requests an award of attorney’s fees on appeal under the prevailing-party provision in the PSA. This provision does not govern our award of fees on appeal. Bobrow v. Bobrow, 241 Ariz. 592, 598–99 (App. 2017).
In our discretion, we decline to award Wife attorney’s fees under A.R.S. § 25-324.
If you have questions about the division of deferred retirement option plans in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona community property and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in community property and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona child custody or family law case around today.
More Articles About Community Property Laws in Arizona
- ARIZONA COMMUNITY PROPERTY LAWS
- CALCULATING A COMMUNITY LIEN ON AN APPRECIATING ASSET IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- VALUING GOODWILL OF A LAWFIRM IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- COMMUNITY PROPERTY AND ANNULMENT OF MARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- SOLE AND SEPARATE FUNDS USED TO BUY A HOUSE IN ARIZONA
- DIVISION OF MILITARY RETIREMENT AND DISABILITY PAYMENTS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- SEPARATE PROPERTY CONTRIBUTIONS WHEN DIVIDING COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- PROPERTY HELD AS JOINT TENANTS WITH RIGHTS OF SURVIVORSHIP IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DIVIDING RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- ARIZONA DIVORCE DEBT
- EFFECT OF PLACING COMMUNITY PROPERTY INTO A FAMILY TRUST IN ARIZONA
- COMMUNITY PROPERTY LOTTERY WINNINGS IN ARIZONA
- IS SEPARATE PROPERTY LIABLE FOR COMMUNITY DEBT IN ARIZONA
- CREDITOR COLLECTING A SEPARATE DEBT WITH COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- TITLE AFFECTS COMMUNITY PROPERTY RIGHTS IN ARIZONA
- COMMINGLING SEPARATE PROPERTY WITH COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- ARE MILITARY RETIREMENT PAYMENTS COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- EFFORT DOES NOT ENTITLE A SPOUSE TO MORE COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- RESULT OF COMMINGLING COMMUNITY AND SEPARATE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- INCREASED VALUE OF A BUSINESS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- GIFT OF SEPARATE PROPERTY THROUGH A JOINT TENANCY DEED IN ARIZONA
- ABANDONMENT OF MARRIAGE AND COMMUNITY PROPERTY RIGHTS IN ARIZONA
- ARE PROFITS FROM A SEPARATE BUSINESS COMMUNITY OR SEPARATE PROPERTY
- TRACING SEPARATE PROPERTY COMMINGLED WITH COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- INTENTION CONTROLS TRANSMUTATION OF SEPARATE INTO COMMUNITY PROPERTY
- RECORDING A HOME IS INSUFFICIENT TO CHANGE SEPARATE PROPERTY INTO COMMUNITY PROPERTY
- COMMUNITY PROPERTY INTEREST IN A BUSINESS OWNED PRIOR TO MARRIAGE
- WHAT IS SEPARATE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- VALUATION AND DISTRIBUTION OPTIONS FOR A PENSION IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- UNFAIR SEPARATION AGREEMENT IN ARIZONA
- UNEQUAL DIVISION OF PROPERTY IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- SEPARATE PROPERTY USED PURCHSE A HOME DURING MARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- REIMBURSEMENT FOR PAYING SEPARATE DEBTS OF A SPOUSE IN ARIZONA
- REFUSAL TO SELL A HOUSE AFTER A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- PENSIONS AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- MILITARY RETIREMENT PAY AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- IS SEPARATE PROPERTY DIVIDED DIFFERENTLY THAN COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- IS ARIZONA A 50-50 STATE IN A DIVORCE
- IS ALL PROPERTY OWNED BY EITHER SPOUSE COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- INTEREST ON A LOAN BETWEEN SPOUSES IN ARIZONA
- IMPACT OF IMPROVEMENTS TO SEPARATE PROPERTY IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- HOW TO ENFORCE DIVISION OF PROPERTY AND DEBT IN ARIZONA
- HOW TO DIVIDE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA WHEN A SPOUSE IS HIDING ASSETS
- HOW STOCK OPTIONS ARE DIVIDED IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- HOW IS COMMUNITY PROPERTY DIVIDED IN ARIZONA
- HOW ARE RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS DIVIDED IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- FILING A LIS PENDENS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- FAIR COMPENSATION DEFENSE IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- ENFORCE A PROPERTY SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT IN ARIZONA
- DO RULES REGARDING PROPERTY APPLY TO DEBTS IN ARIZONA
- DIVISION OF DEBT IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DIVIDING PROPERTY NOT INCLUDED IN A DIVORCE DECREE IN ARIZONA
- DIFFERENCE IN COMMUNITY AND SEPARATE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- DETERMINING COMMUNITY VERSUS SOLE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- CREATION OF A COMMUNITY LIEN ON SOLE AND SEPARATE PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- COMMUNITY PROPERTY LAWS ABOUT A SPOUSE’S PERSONAL GUARANTEE IN ARIZONA
- CHOOSING A VALUATION DATE WHEN DIVIDING ASSETS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- CAN A SPOUSE BE HELD LIABLE FOR CREDIT CARD DEBT IN ARIZONA
- CALCULATING A COMMUNITY LIEN ON A DEPRECIATING ASSET IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF A DISCLAIMER DEED OR QUIT CLAIM DEED IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- BANK ACCOUNTS AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- DIVIDING PAID TIME OFF IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- EQUALIZATION PAYMENTS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- OMITTED ASSETS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE DECREE
- CRSC PAY AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- JUDGMENT FOR SEPARATE PROPERTY STOLEN DURING MARRIAGE
- JUDGE IGNORES A BUSINESS APPRAISAL IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- REIMBURSEMENT OF SEPARATE PROPERTY IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- SEPARATE PROPERTY INCREASES IN VALUE DURING MARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- PERSONAL INJURY AWARDS AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- VALUING A BUSINESS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA WITHOUT FINANCIAL DOCUMENTATION
- RETIREMENT INCREASE AFTER DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- FAILURE TO DISCLOSE FINANCIAL INFORMATION IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- UNAUTHORIZED USE OF A POWER OF ATTORNEY TO DISPOSE OF SPOUSE’S SEPARATE PROPERTY
- COHABITATION AGREEMENTS IN ARIZONA
- FINANCIAL AGREEMENTS BETWEEN UNMARRIED COUPLES IN ARIZONA
- COMMUNITY PROPERTY LIABILITY EXISTS EVEN AFTER PROBATE ENDS
- WHEN A CREDITOR MAY TAKE SOLE AND SEPARATE ASSETS OF A SPOUSE
- LIABILITY FOR A SPOUSE’S NEGLIGENCE IN ARIZONA
- VALUATION OF STOCK HOLDINGS AND DEBT IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- LOANS BEFORE MARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- CREDITOR LIEN ON JOINT TENANCY PROPERTY IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- INCREASE IN VALUE OF A SEPARATE PROPERTY BUSINESS STOCK IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- STATEMENTS REGARDING PROPERTY ARE BINDING IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DEBTS NOT INCLUDED IN A DIVORCE DECREE IN ARIZONA
- FRAUDULENT QUIT CLAIM DEED IS INEFFECTIVE IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DISPOSITION OF COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN A LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT
- DIVIDING BUSINESS PROFITS DURING A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- MINORITY DISCOUNT IN A BUSINESS VALUATION IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- HOW A BUSINESS IS DIVIDED IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- DIVISION OF CIVIL SERVICE RETIREMENT SYSTEM BENEFITS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- DISABILITY PAY AND COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- VALUATION OF A PROFESSIONAL PRACTICE IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- JOINING A THIRD PARTY IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- CONTESTING A RULE 69 AGREEMENT WITHOUT A TRIAL IN ARIZONA
- DEFENSE TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR PAYMENT OF COMMUNITY BILLS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- SURVIVOR ELECTION AND MILITARY RETIREMENT IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DEFERRED MILITARY RETIREMENT IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- CLAIMS OF WASTE IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DIVIDING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- THE IMPORTANCE OF TITLE SEARCHES ON THE MARITAL HOME DURING A DIVORCE
- FRAUDULENT CONVEYANCE IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- MINORITY DISCOUNT BUSINESS APPRAISAL IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- FINDING A REALTOR DURING A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- MILITARY BENEFITS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- WHAT TO DO IF YOUR SPOUSE IS HIDING ASSETS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- TYPES OF BUSINESS APPRAISALS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- BENEFICIARY DESIGNATIONS AFTER DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- RETIREMENT ACCOUNTS, QDROs, AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- DIVORCE AND REFINANCING A MORTGAGE IN ARIZONA
- PROVING PROPERTY IS SOLE AND SEPARATE IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- 7 REASONS YOU MAY HAVE TO SHARE YOUR INJURY SETTLEMENT IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- PERSONAL INJURY SETTLEMENT IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- CLAIM OF A SPOUSE’S PERSONAL INJURY AWARD IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- PERSONAL INJURY AWARDS AND DIVORCE SETTLEMENTS IN ARIZONA
- PROTECTING YOUR PERSONAL INJURY AWARD IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- DIVORCE AND PERSONAL INJURY AWARDS IN ARIZONA
- ENFORCING A SURVIVOR BENEFIT ELECTION IN A PENSION IN ARIZONA
- MURDERER SPOUSE AND COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- DAMAGES CAUSED BY A COMMUNITY PROPERTY VEHICLE IN ARIZONA
- COMPENSATION FOR WASTE OF COMMUNITY ASSETS IN ARIZONA
- USING SEPARATE FUNDS TO BUY JOINT PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- TRANSMUTING SEPARATE PROPERTY INTO COMMUNITY PROPERTY BY COMMINGLING
- LIABILITY FOR DEBT GUARANTEED BY THE OTHER SPOUSE IN ARIZONA
- USING COMMUNITY FUNDS TO PAY A MORTGAGE ON A SPOUSE’S SOLE AND SEPARATE HOUSE
- DISCLAIMER DEED AND DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- COMMUNITY LIEN ON A SOLE AND SEPARATE BUSINESS IN A DIVORCE IN ARIZONA
- YOU’RE GETTING A DIVORCE, ARE YOU SURE YOU WANT THE HOUSE?
- CHANGING JOINT PROPERTY TO COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- SEGREGATING SEPARATE PROPERTY FROM COMMUNITY PROPERTY IN ARIZONA
- ARIZONA COMMUNITY PROPERTY LAWS FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS