Logo
Call Now(480) 305-8300

Use of the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act in Arizona Paternity Cases

Posted on : October 11, 2016, By:  Christopher Hildebrand
Use of the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act in Arizona Paternity Cases

Use of the Uniform Declaratory Judgements Act in Arizona Paternity Cases

Arizona law only allows parents the right to file for custody of a child. In cases of children born out of wedlock, a man has to prove paternity before being entitled to visitation with his child. However, for many years putative fathers had a hard time opening a paternity action. Current Arizona law allows putative fathers to file paternity actions, but this wasn’t always the case.

Prior law only allowed mothers to file paternity actions. Did this mean that, under prior law, a putative father could never prove paternity to seek custody absent action by the mother? The Court of Appeals addressed this issue in Thornsberry v. Superior Court, Mohave County, 707 P. 2d 315(1985).
Use of the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act Arizona Paternity Cases

Facts of the Case

Mrs. Thornsberry was the mother of a child, K. Thornsberry, born on June 30, 1982. Mr. Hunter said that he was K. Thornsberry’s father. He sought visitation rights under A.R.S. §§ 25-331, -337, Arizona’s child custody statutes. Mrs. Thornsberry argued that a proceeding under the child custody statutes can only be brought by a parent. The lower court agreed. The Court of Appeals accepted special action jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction to Assert Paternity under the Custody and Paternity Statutes

Arizona law was recently amended. These amendments apply only prospectively. However, since this case occurred before the amendments, the Court of Appeals reviewed prior law. Under prior law, a court could only grant visitation rights in a “jurisdictionally sound” custody proceeding. The statute — A.R.S. § 25-331—required that the proceeding be brought by a parent. Mr. Thornsberry’s claim of paternity in the custody pleadings didn’t give him jurisdiction to file for custody. Mrs. Thornsberry also argued that Mr. Thornsberry lacked jurisdiction to file a paternity complaint.

Under prior law, only the county attorney or a mother could file a paternity complaint under A.R.S. § 12-846. The putative father had no right to do so. The Court agreed with Mrs. Thornsberry’s legal arguments.

Jurisdiction under the Uniform Act

Mrs. Thornsberry next argued that Mr. Thornsberry has no legal manner of getting a court determination of paternity. The Court of Appeals rejected this position. The Court noted that the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act is found at A.R.S. § 12-1831 through 12-1846. It permits courts to declare status and legal relations. Mr. Thornsberry sought a determination of paternity to establish jurisdiction to claim his visitation rights. The Court said that it would be unconstitutional if he were not permitted a forum to seek visitation.
Use of the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act in Arizona Paternity Cases

Arizona courts have never held that the paternity law is the only way a putative father can determine paternity. Other states allow a putative father to establish paternity by declaratory judgment in these circumstances. The Arizona legislature recently amended the paternity law to permit a putative father to bring a suit himself. And, under the new law, the father can adjudicate visitation rights in the paternity action.

The Court agreed that the amendments did not apply to Mr. Thornsberry, since they only apply prospectively. However, the Court said, they indicate legislative intent. They found that allowing Mr. Thornsberry to adjudicate paternity through declaratory judgment is completely in line with legislative intent.

Disposition

The Court of Appeals vacated the trial court’s order and dismissed the Mr. Thornsberry’s petition. However, the Court did so without prejudice. It suggested that Mr. Thornsberry file an amended complaint under the Uniform Declaratory Judgments Act.


Meet Our Scottsdale Arizona Divorce Attorneys

What’s Hot – Blog

Hildeband Law, PC.