Table of Contents
In Arizona, spousal support begins on a specific day and continues for the time specified in the divorce decree. Under the law, a spouse may bring a petition to enforce the order at any time up to three years after the time the spousal support terminates.
What happens when a spouse repeatedly promises to pay but remains in arrears for years after the support was supposed to be paid? Can the other spouse still bring a petition? In Ames vs. Ames No. 1 CA-CV 15-0013 FC, filed March 10, 2016, the Arizona Court of Appeals discussed whether these kinds of assurances alter the three-year period in which to bring an enforcement action.
Facts of the Case
Julie and Gene Ames ended their marriage in 2003. The decree of dissolution ordered Gene to pay Julie $1,000 each month for four years. Gene did not keep up with those payments but repeatedly promised to make up the payments when he was able. In 2014, Julie filed a petition to enforce the support order.
bout $30,000 had not been paid. Gene made an oral motion to dismiss the petition. He claimed that it was barred by the three-year statute of limitations for enforcing support orders. The court took the matter under advisement. When it issued its ruling, it agreed with Gene that the petition was filed too late, and dismissed it. Julie appealed.
Julie claimed that she was denied due process because she was not given a chance to present written briefing to the court. The Court of Appeals noted that Julie told the divorce court she had anticipated and addressed Gene’s statute of limitations argument in her briefing after consulting an attorney. It further noted that she had not identified any other evidence she wanted to present. Therefore, the Court found that Julie’s due process rights were not violated.
The Application of the Statute of Limitations
The written law setting out a three-year time period to bring an action to enforce spousal support payments is found at A.R.S. § 25-553A: The person to whom the spousal maintenance obligation is owed may file a request for judgment for spousal maintenance arrearages not later than three years after the date the spousal maintenance order terminates. Julie argued that this statute did not apply to her case, because, she claimed, no time was set in the divorce decree for the spousal payment order to terminate.
She says that Gene owed her $48,000 and that the spousal would not terminate until he paid it. The Court did not agree with this position. It said that the clear language of the Ames’ decree set spousal payments for four years. The period began as soon as the decree was entered, and it terminated four years later, that is, in 2007. Julie then had three years – until 2010 – to file a petition to enforce the decree. She did not file until 2014, so the petition was too late. It was barred by the statute of limitations.
Extension by Agreement
Julie argued that Gene’s communications with her promising to pay when he found another job essentially extended the three-year statute of limitations. However, the Court did not agree. Although the emails from Gene that Julie submitted to the Court showed that Gene regretted not being able to pay and hoped he would be able to pay in the future, there was no discussion of extending the statute of limitations for her to bring an action.
Julie argues that enforcement of spousal maintenance should be treated the same as child support collections actions since the policy arguments for the two are the same. She points to the law governing the collection of back child support following the termination of a child support order. Under the law, the paying parent must prove that the other parent “unreasonably delayed” in attempting to collect the back support before the statute of limitations is imposed.
The Court of Appeals noted that the legislature could have put this language in the spousal support statute but did not do so. The Court also said that the shorter time frame is consistent with the purpose of spousal support in Arizona — to encourage a transition to independence. The Court of Appeals ruled against Julie. It affirmed the divorce court’s dismissal of her petition because it was barred by the three-year statute of limitations.
If you need information about the statute of limitations for alimony in Arizona, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona alimony attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in divorce cases in Arizona.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona alimony case around today.
Other Articles About Arizona Spousal Maintenance Laws
- RULES FOR INDEFINITE OR LIFETIME SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- ARIZONA ALIMONY AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE LAWS
- ATTRIBUTING INCOME FOR SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN ARIZONA
- WHO QUALIFIES FOR SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- TERMINATION OF ALIMONY UPON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF MERGER ON MODIFICATION OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF CDRP PAY ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- MILITARY DISABILITY AND ARIZONA ALIMONY
- VA DISABILITY BENEFITS AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- AMBIGUOUS ALIMONY TERMS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE DECREE
- CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHAT DOCTORS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF EXCESSIVE SPENDING ON A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WAIVING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN A PRENUPTIAL AGREEMENT IN ARIZONA
- ALIMONY AND OVERTIME IN ARIZONA
- CREDIT FOR DIRECT PAYMENTS OF SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- WAIVER OF SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- THE DATE COURTS USE FOR A CHANGE IN CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHEN DOES SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE TERMINATE ON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- DEFENSES TO NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- CATEGORIES OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- NOT SUPPORTING YOURSELF WILL NOT EXTEND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF SHARING LIVING EXPENSES ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- ALIMONY IN ARIZONA FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
- ARE THE COSTS OF HEALTH INSURANCE CONSIDERED FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES
- CAN YOU MODIFY OR TERMINATE ALIMONY EARLY IN ARIZONA
- CONTINUING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE AFTER DEATH OF A FORMER SPOUSE IN ARIZONA
- DENIAL OF SPOUSAL SUPPORT AS A SANCTION IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- EMPLOYMENT HISTORY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- HOW DO THE ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES WORK
- HOW LONG DO YOU HAVE TO BE MARRIED TO GET ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- IS ALIMONY IN ARIZONA TAXABLE INCOME
- LIVING TOGETHER AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- MODIFYING NON-MODIFIABLE ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN ARIZONA
- PROBLEMS WITH ARIZONA ALIMONY CALCULATORS
- STANDARD OF LIVING AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- STOP SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE PAYMENTS IN ARIZONA
- TERMINATE ALIMONY UPON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- VETERANS DISABILITY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHAT EFFECT DO CHILDREN’S COLLEGE COSTS HAVE ON ALIMONY ARIZONA
- DOCTORS FACING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE ISSUES IN ARIZONA
About the Author: Chris Hildebrand has over 26 years of Arizona family law experience and received awards from US News and World Report, Phoenix Magazine, Arizona Foothills Magazine and others. Visit https://www.hildebrandlaw.com.