Attributing Income for Spousal Support in Arizona
We want to talk to you about attributing income for spousal support in Arizona. A court may, in some cases, decide to attribute income in a spousal maintenance case if the court feels a person is unemployed or underemployed in an Arizona divorce.
In its published decision in Pullen v. Pullen, 223 Ariz. 293 (App. 2009), the Arizona Court of Appeals examined when to attribute income in a spousal maintenance case.
Husband and Wife were married in 1978. After 29 years of marriage, Wife filed a petition for dissolution of marriage and requested spousal maintenance.
Prior to her petition, the Wife was unemployed. At the time of trial, Wife was making $9.02 per hour, or $12,191 annually, as a special education teaching assistant. Prior to trial, Husband was a driver for FedEx in Kingman making $64,988 annually.
After Wife filed her petition, Husband voluntarily ended his employment at FedEx and moved to Washington. At the time of trial, Husband was employed as a driver in Washington making $15 per hour. Husband asserted that he chose Washington even though FedEx would not transfer him there and that due to the economy, he accepted a lower-paying job.
The trial court found that Husband was voluntarily underemployed, attributed him his income from FedEx, and determined that Wife was entitled to alimony of $1,000 per month for ten years. The husband appealed, arguing that the trial court applied the wrong standard for attributing his income and the evidence did not support the finding that he was voluntarily underemployed.
Balancing Test for Attributing Income in a Spousal Support Case
The Court of Appeals examined the Supreme Court’s prior decision in Little v. Little, 193 Ariz. 518, 975 P.2d 108 (1999) where it adopted an intermediate balancing test to determine whether to use actual income or earning capacity to calculate child support when a parent voluntarily reduces their income. The Court of Appeals found that the following five factors should be used when applying the balancing test to a spousal maintenance case:
- The reasons asserted by the party whose conduct is at issue;
- The impact upon the obligee of considering the actual earnings of the obligor;
- When the obligee’s conduct is at issue, the impact upon the obligor of considering the actual earnings of the oblige and thereby reducing the obligor’s financial contribution to the support order at issue;
- Whether the party complaining of a voluntary reduction in income acquiesced in the conduct of the other party; and
- The timing of the action in question in relation to the entering of a decree or the execution of a written agreement between the parties.
The Court found that although the trial court did not expressly consider the five factors, the record supported the trial court’s decision under the five-factor analysis.
Weighing the Evidence to Attribute Prior Income
Husband also argued that the evidence was insufficient to show that he was voluntarily underemployed. The Court of Appeals disagreed and found that if the Husband wanted to move from Arizona, he could have transferred with FedEx to Nevada or California. The Court found that it was within the trial court’s discretion to find that the Husband’s voluntary move to Washington was unreasonable, considering Wife’s pending maintenance needs.
If you have questions about attributing income for spousal support in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona community property and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in community property disputes and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona community property or family law case around today.
Other Articles About Spousal Maintenance in Arizona
- WHAT EFFECT DOES CHILDREN’S COLLEGE COSTS HAVE ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EMPLOYMENT HISTORY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- VETERANS DISABILITY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- MODIFYING NON-MODIFIABLE ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- STOP SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE PAYMENTS IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- PROBLEMS WITH ARIZONA ALIMONY CALCULATORS | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- HOW DO THE ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES WORK
- LIVING TOGETHER AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW
- CAN YOU MODIFY OR TERMINATE ALIMONY EARLY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- ARE THE COSTS OF HEALTH INSURANCE CONSIDERED FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHAT EFFECT DOES EXCESSIVE SPENDING HAVE ON A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- STANDARD OF LIVING AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC.
- ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- TERMINATE ALIMONY UPON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- IS ALIMONY IN ARIZONA TAXABLE INCOME | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- HOW LONG DO YOU HAVE TO BE MARRIED TO GET ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- DENIAL OF SPOUSAL SUPPORT AS A SANCTION IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE | HILDEBRAND LAW
- CONTINUING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE AFTER THE DEATH OF A FORMER SPOUSE IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF MERGER ON MODIFICATION OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- THE EFFECT OF THE 2017 TAX BILL ON DIVORCE IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- EFFECT OF CDRP PAY ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- TERMINATION OF ALIMONY ON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- MILITARY DISABILITY AND ARIZONA ALIMONY | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- VA DISABILITY BENEFITS PAID FOR ALIMONY IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW
- STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- AMBIGUOUS ALIMONY TERMS IN AN AZ DIVORCE | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- NOT SUPPORTING YOURSELF WILL NOT EXTEND ALIMONY IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW
- WAIVING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN A PRENUPTIAL AGREEMENT IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF SHARING LIVING EXPENSES ON ALIMONY IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW
- DIVISION OF PROPERTY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- ALIMONY AGREEMENT MAY AFFECT MODIFICATION IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- CATEGORIES OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- DEFENSES TO NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- WHEN DOES ALIMONY TERMINATE ON REMARRIAGE IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW
- DATE FOR CHANGE IN CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY AZ ALIMONY | HILDEBRAND LAW
- WAIVER OF SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- OVERTIME AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC
- ALIMONY AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE LAWS IN AZ | HILDEBRAND LAW, PC