Not Supporting Yourself Will Not Extend Alimony in AZ | Hildebrand Law
Table of Contents
In Arizona, the family court’s denial of a petition to modify spousal maintenance can be appealed. On appeal, the Arizona Court of Appeals typically does not consider new evidence but will reconsider the facts of the case in search of an abuse of discretion on the part of the court.
A Brief History of the Case: Green v. Green
The Greens divorced in 2005 at which time Wife met the criteria under Arizona state law to be awarded spousal maintenance. Accordingly, Husband was ordered to pay wife spousal maintenance of $1,925 per month for nine years. Four months prior to the nine-year mark, Wife petitioned the court to modify spousal maintenance with an increased monthly payment to continue indefinitely.
The modification was requested based on her assertion that substantial and continuing changes in her own financial circumstances, as well as a medical condition, called for it. The wife presented evidence at an evidentiary hearing and the superior court denied her request. She appealed.
Discussing Issues of Law on Appeal: Green v. Green
On appeal, Wife alleges that the superior court erred in its denial of her Petition to Modify Spousal Maintenance. The Court of Appeals of Arizona will review the trial court’s dismissal for an abuse of discretion. The court may order a modification of a spousal maintenance award if the party can establish a continuing and substantial change in circumstances (per A.R.S. Section 25-327(A).
In order to determine if the circumstances have changed, the court compares the current economic circumstances with those that existed at the time the original decree/award was granted. Factors considered include financial resources of both parties and the ability to generate income on the part of the party receiving the award, among other factors.
Wife’s assertion that her circumstances changed after the 2005 divorce decree was based on an increase in expenses combined with an inability to increase her income and development of a medical condition that made working difficult.
She testified regarding her work history since the divorce (as a para-educator paid $10.85/hour nine months each year). She had not pursued any additional education or training to obtain additional job qualifications.
Additional testimony was offered regarding the Wife’s development of painful medical conditions and deteriorating health that would limit her ability to perform work tasks. She did testify upon further questioning that she was still able to work and that her physician had not advised her not to work.
The superior court found that Wife failed to prove the existence of a substantial and continuing change in circumstances and, therefore, denied her Petition to Modify Spousal Maintenance. The court noted she made no efforts to increase her income to meet her own living expenses, followed her physician’s recommendations in regards to medical conditions or changed her occupation in order to address her health complaints in relation to employment.
The wife argues that the court erred in focusing on her “failure” to increase her income as Arizona law does not require individuals in receipt of spousal maintenance to increase their earning potential and there was evidence that her expenses had increased to exceed her income.
However, Wife’s argument fails to address the issue that evidence established that her financial circumstances had not changed since the original spousal maintenance award. As the family court’s ruling was based on substantial evidence, there is no abuse of discretion in the denial of the Wife’s petition to modify.
In Conclusion: The Arizona Court of Appeals Decision in Green v. Green
The Arizona Court of Appeals affirmed the family court’s decision as the court found no abuse of discretion in its decision and ample evidence supported its findings.
If you have questions about failure increase income not basis to extend alimony in an Arizona divorce case, you should seriously consider contacting the attorneys at Hildebrand Law, PC. Our Arizona spousal maintenance and family law attorneys have over 100 years of combined experience successfully representing clients in spousal maintenance and family law cases.
Our family law firm has earned numerous awards such as US News and World Reports Best Arizona Family Law Firm, US News and World Report Best Divorce Attorneys, “Best of the Valley” by Arizona Foothills readers, and “Best Arizona Divorce Law Firms” by North Scottsdale Magazine.
Call us today at (480)305-8300 or reach out to us through our appointment scheduling form to schedule your personalized consultation and turn your Arizona spousal maintenance or family law case around today.
Other Articles About Spousal Maintenance in Arizona
- RULES FOR INDEFINITE OR LIFETIME SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- ARIZONA ALIMONY AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE LAWS
- ATTRIBUTING INCOME FOR SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN ARIZONA
- WHO QUALIFIES FOR SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- TERMINATION OF ALIMONY UPON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF MERGER ON MODIFICATION OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF CDRP PAY ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- MILITARY DISABILITY AND ARIZONA ALIMONY
- VA DISABILITY BENEFITS AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- AMBIGUOUS ALIMONY TERMS IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE DECREE
- CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHAT DOCTORS SHOULD KNOW ABOUT ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF EXCESSIVE SPENDING ON A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WAIVING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN A PRENUPTIAL AGREEMENT IN ARIZONA
- ALIMONY AND OVERTIME IN ARIZONA
- CREDIT FOR DIRECT PAYMENTS OF SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- WAIVER OF SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- THE DATE COURTS USE FOR A CHANGE IN CIRCUMSTANCES TO MODIFY ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHEN DOES SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE TERMINATE ON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- DEFENSES TO NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- CATEGORIES OF ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- EFFECT OF SHARING LIVING EXPENSES ON ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- ALIMONY IN ARIZONA FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
- ARE THE COSTS OF HEALTH INSURANCE CONSIDERED FOR ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES
- CAN YOU MODIFY OR TERMINATE ALIMONY EARLY IN ARIZONA
- CONTINUING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE AFTER DEATH OF A FORMER SPOUSE IN ARIZONA
- DENIAL OF SPOUSAL SUPPORT AS A SANCTION IN AN ARIZONA DIVORCE
- EMPLOYMENT HISTORY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- HOW DO THE ARIZONA SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE GUIDELINES WORK
- HOW LONG DO YOU HAVE TO BE MARRIED TO GET ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- IS ALIMONY IN ARIZONA TAXABLE INCOME
- LIVING TOGETHER AND SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE IN ARIZONA
- MODIFYING NON-MODIFIABLE ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- NON-MODIFIABLE SPOUSAL SUPPORT IN ARIZONA
- PROBLEMS WITH ARIZONA ALIMONY CALCULATORS
- STANDARD OF LIVING AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- STOP SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE PAYMENTS IN ARIZONA
- TERMINATE ALIMONY UPON REMARRIAGE IN ARIZONA
- VETERANS DISABILITY AND ALIMONY IN ARIZONA
- WHAT EFFECT DO CHILDREN’S COLLEGE COSTS HAVE ON ALIMONY ARIZONA
- DOCTORS FACING SPOUSAL MAINTENANCE ISSUES IN ARIZONA
As Seen on CBS News, ABC News, NBC News, and Fox News